This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Prepared Foods logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Prepared Foods logo
  • Home
  • Trends
    • 2020 Trends
    • 2019 Trends
    • 2018 Trends
  • Products
    • Bakery
    • Beverages
    • Breakfast, Cereals & Bars
    • Cannabis
    • Dairy
    • Meals & Sides
    • Meat, Poultry & Seafood
    • Sauces & Marinades
    • Snacks & Appetizers
    • Soups
    • Food & Beverage Product Videos
  • Ingredients
    • Phosphates & Acidulants
    • Antioxidants & Nutritionals
    • Batters, Breading & Coatings
    • Cheese, Sauces & Bases
    • Colorings
    • Dietary Fiber
    • Emulsifiers, Fat & Oils
    • Flavors, Seasonings, Spices
    • Flours, Grains, & Pasta
    • Fruits, Vegetables and Nuts
    • Gums & Starches
    • Proteins & Enzymes
    • Sweeteners
  • Formulation
    • Allergens & Intolerance
    • Gluten Free
    • Authentic & Ethnic
    • Calorie Reduction
    • Cost Reduction
    • Fat Reduction
    • Organic & Natural
    • Shelf Stability
    • Sugar & Sodium Reduction
    • Weight Management
    • Vegetarian
    • R&D Lab Tech / QA-QC / Food Safety
  • Better for You
    • Functional New Products
    • Functional Ingredients
    • Functional Benefits
  • Food Master
  • Multimedia
    • Favorite Products Poll
    • Videos
    • Image Galleries
    • Interactive Spotlight
    • Polls
  • More
    • eNewsletter Archives
    • Events
      • New Product Conference
      • Spirit of Innovation Awards
      • Industry Events
      • Webinars
    • Prepared Foods Store
    • White Papers
    • First Person Q&A
    • 19 Product Development Resources
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Editions
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
Home » NYC Ban on Trans Fat: A Case Study
Regulations & Claims

NYC Ban on Trans Fat: A Case Study

January 1, 2007
Steven B. Steinborn
Reprints
No Comments

A recent ban of trans fat from restaurant foods by New York City’s (NYC) Board of Public Health broke new ground in the world of product development. While much of the food industry has devoted substantial efforts to removing or reducing trans fat levels, New York City now imposes a level of interference that many believe will do more harm than good. The public focus on trans fat content was propelled by the mandatory labeling requirement for packaged foods effective January 1, 2006, per the FDA. Savvy regulatory affairs experts would have bet wisely that the “regulatory action” on trans fat was over, and companies would continue to remove trans fat from foods. NYC decided otherwise.

Another seemingly safe bet? A well-intentioned government agency would not unilaterally act to ban a nutrient because it is considered of public health concern. After all, no one ever banned cholesterol- or sodium-containing foods. The wisdom and lawfulness of the unprecedented action by NYC are important questions, though not addressed in this article. Instead, the trans fat ban provides insight into the dynamics of product reformulation, the impediments to achieving change and the potential unintended consequences of regulatory intervention.

The Ban

The board kept its promise to rid NYC restaurants of trans fat. While claiming to have taken into account industry concerns, the ban will wreak havoc on both ongoing and new reformulation efforts. The prospects that other local jurisdictions might follow NYC’s lead (on trans fat or any other nutrient of local concern) may well change the way companies manage product development efforts. After July 2007, it will be illegal for restaurants to use cooking oil that contains trans fat. By July 2008, restaurants will no longer be permitted to sell any foods that contain trans fat.

Regulatory intervention does not change the fundamental barriers and hurdles faced by the food industry in trying to eliminate trans fat. Several restaurant chains have announced plans to move to 0g trans fat cooking oils after investing years in achieving a reformulation that did not negatively impact taste or nutrition. Many others are still working. The pace of change is dictated by factors that cannot somehow be regulated away.

Food companies must address three types of challenges—availability, functionality and cost. The cultivation of alternative oils takes time, including perfecting suitable seeds before crops can be planted and then processed in sufficient quantities to meet commercial demand. Supply levels are expected to hamper changes away from current oils for at least several years, with growing demand imposing greater costs until supply catches up.

Reformulation is time-consuming and complicated. Not all oils are created equal. Oxidative stability (melting point, shelflife, off-flavors) and “hardness” of fat (texture and crispness) are two key variables, and suitability will vary with the food and process involved. Switching to a commercially available alternative may remove unwanted trans fat, but there is no benefit if the reformulated product is unacceptable to consumers

Unintended Consequences

Absent viable alternatives, operators will turn to traditional higher saturated-fat cooking. This outcome has nothing to do with good or bad intentions by the restaurant, but rather reflects the realities of product reformulation.

The city’s legal authority is also in doubt given that Congress long ago established a federal framework for the regulation of safe and suitable foods given the realities of a national marketplace. Imagine if each jurisdiction were left free to pick its “nutrient of choice” to ban?

Diet and health will continue to prompt product innovation. Ongoing efforts will continue to yield success in formulating out trans fat from foods. A government ban does not remove the barriers to more rapid innovation.

Subscribe to Prepared Foods

Recent Articles by Steven Steinborn

Food Labeling and the Laws

New Look Labels: Added Sugars

The Future of Genetically Engineered Foods

FDA Rules for Menu, Labeling, Vending

FDA Nutrition Labeling Changes

Steven B. Steinborn is a partner with Hogan Lovells’ in Washington DC. Steinborn literally wrote the book on food labeling as a principal author of the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) labeling guide. He offers clients 28 years of experience in guiding informed business decisions, taking into account food laws and other regulations, as well as the environment in which companies operate. Readers may contact him at steven.steinborn@hoganlovells.com.

A top 12 law firm, Hogan Lovells International LLP (www.hoganlovells) is global company with 41 offices worldwide, more than 2,500 lawyers and 800 partners.

Related Articles

FDA Reviews GRAS Status of PHOs

FSIS Proposed Rule on Raw Meat/Poultry

Impact of FSMA on Food Product R&D

The Impact of FSMA on the Food Product Development Process

Related Products

FEMA 100 - A Century of Great Taste

Optimizing Social Media from a B2B Perspective

ForeSights: Cannabidiol - A natural compound in cannabis renowned for its health properties

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • Print & Digital Edition Subscriptions
  • Prepared Foods eNewsletter
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service

More Videos

Popular Stories

Innova_StreetCouple_900

Innova Market Insights Top Trends for 2020

SFA_900

2020 Food Trend Predictions

Cannabinoids Molecules Graphic

Beyond CBD and THC: Other cannabinoids offer possibilities for cannabis edibles

BlueDiamond_Pickle_900

Blue Diamond Spicy Dill Pickle Almonds

Fi_Ni_900

Fi Europe & Ni Opens in December

Prepared Foods Favorite Products Poll

Events

January 1, 2030

Webinar Sponsorship Information

For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

View All Submit An Event

Poll

BEST SNACKS OF 2019

Which is your favorite snack launch from 2019?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

Accelerating New Food Product Design and Development, 2nd Edition

Accelerating New Food Product Design and Development, 2nd Edition

See More Products

Prepared Foods

Prepared Foods December 2019 Cover

2019 December

Check out the December 2019 issue of Prepared Foods, featuring food and beverage industry trend predictions for 2020!

View More Create Account
  • More
    • Want More
    • Connect
    • Editorial Guidelines
    • New Product Submission Form
    • Food & Beverage Brands
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey And Sample
    • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise With Us
    • Advertise
  • Subscribe

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing